Proprietary trading firm My Forex Funds and its CEO, Murtuza Kazmi, are reportedly in negotiations with U.S. and Canadian regulators over a potential settlement, following lawsuits alleging fraud. This development comes after significant regulatory action from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC).
Legal Battle and Business Disruption
In August 2023, the CFTC accused My Forex Funds and Kazmi of defrauding customers. According to the complaint, the firm generated at least $310 million in fees from its proprietary trading platform, which attracted over 135,000 clients between November 2021 and its closure. The charges led to a temporary restraining order, an asset freeze, and the business shutting down overnight.
The defendants have challenged the allegations, claiming the asset freeze was based on misrepresented facts by the CFTC. They argued that the regulator acted in “bad faith,” prompting a motion for sanctions against the CFTC.
Industry Impact
The lawsuit has sent shockwaves through the proprietary trading industry, with many firms adjusting their marketing language to include terms like “simulated” and “virtual” to avoid similar scrutiny. The case highlights growing regulatory focus on the transparency of prop trading business models.
Criticism of the CFTC
The CFTC’s actions in this case have faced criticism, including from within its own ranks. Commissioner Caroline Pham publicly questioned the regulator’s approach, suggesting lapses in professional ethics. Additionally, Republican Senator Charles Grassley raised concerns about the CFTC’s administrative process, seeking clarification on whether disciplinary measures were taken against staff involved in alleged misconduct. While Senator Grassley did not explicitly name My Forex Funds in his inquiry, the lawsuit’s details were indirectly referenced.
Possible Settlement
Sources indicate that negotiations for a settlement are underway, though neither party has confirmed any agreement. A resolution could potentially lead to financial penalties and compliance measures for My Forex Funds, allowing it to resume operations under stricter regulatory oversight.
The case underscores the increasing regulatory scrutiny on proprietary trading platforms and the importance of adhering to transparent and compliant business practices.
